Amateurs who couldn’t turn out a crowd? Corporate shills? Do they not have a coherent message or are they stifled with ideological single-mindedness. Is this a organized but empty protests that won’t translate into electoral results?
This Movement movement has given birth to a new generation of movers and shakers who have rejected establishment partisan politics for nimble, Internet-facilitated, issues-based advocacy. When it comes to a populist progressive movement, this seems to put all the professional community organizers to shame.
Tens of thousands of conservative activists converge on Capitol grounds
By Mike Soraghan - 09/12/09 05:54 PM ET
The conservative activists who took over the west lawn of the Capitol on Saturday made it clear their anger extends far past President Barack Obama's healthcare plan, and even back into the previous administration.
Protesters and speakers used the rally to voice their anger at Obama's stimulus package, the House-passed "cap-and-trade" energy bill, and the $700 billion Wall Street bailout.
But it went well beyond that to include anger about federal funds going to the liberal group Acorn, the number of "czars" appointed in the Obama administration and accusations that the White House solicited critics' e-mails to compile an "enemies list." Others pushed for tort reform and making English the official language and questioned whether Obama was born in the United States.
And they really, really like Rep. Joe Wilson (R-S.C.), who has been thrust into the spotlights of the left and the right after bursting out "You lie!" at Obama's speech to a joint session of Congress on Wednesday.
"It started last year when the Republicans were bailing out Wall Street and started again this year when the Democrats rammed the stimulus down our throats," said Brendan Steinhauser, an organizer for FreedomWorks, which sponsored the rally.
The idea of increased federal involvement in healthcare, many said, simply brought their anger to a boil.
"It's the power being amassed with all these programs," said Carl Hilschur of Luray, Va., who toted a "Joe Wilson for President" sign. "Things are getting to the point where you have to do something. It might not make a difference, but you have to try."
Reliable crowd estimates for the event were not available, and are a likely source of debate between liberal and conservative groups, but the crowd was in the tens of thousands. The crowd filled the west lawn of the Capitol and spread from there. Organizers said 450 buses carried protesters to the march. About 30,000 registered for the march online.
The march and rally were extension of the Tea Party Patriot movement that turned town halls raucous in August. The official name of the event was the "Taxpayer March on Washington," but it was also commonly called the 9-12 march. Several speakers also indicated they plan to hold a similar march next year. If such a march was held at the same time, it would come as the 2010 election season heats up.
Rep. Tom Price (R-Ga.) said from the stage he believed the crowd was bigger than the the one assembled for Obama's inauguration in January.
"It's amazing they got so many people here with so little organization," Sen. Jim DeMint (R-S.C.) said in an interview. DeMint also was a speaker at the rally.
The list of speakers included only a sprinkling of politicians. The highest ranking was Rep. Mike Pence (R-Ind.), chairman of the House Republican Conference. The other politicians on the roster of speakers were Rep. Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.), State Rep. Tom Graves of Georgia and Indiana State Treasurer Richard Mourdock. Former House Majority Leader Dick Armey, now the leader of FreedomWorks, also spoke.
Many of the other speakers represented conservative groups like the National Taxpayers Union and Grassfire.org.
But it was a politician who wasn't there – Wilson – who got the most praise. Wilson's outburst made him a hero to many of the protesters and speakers. "Joe Wilson for President" was a common slogan on signs. Another said "Congress, you're fired. (Except Joe Wilson)."
"He said what 250 million Americans are saying," said Mike Galvin of Troy, N.Y., who carried a Palin-Wilson 2012 sign. "They're the only two politicians in the country with the stones to say what needs to be said."
Galvin said he paid $200 of the $250 he had in the bank to make it to the protest. He rode a bus all night, leaving behind his sick wife, and planned to be back home by midnight. Though he's a disabled veteran, he said he gets health insurance through his accounting job.
“I am here to protest the expansion of government spending,” said Stuwart Ingman of Kansas. Ingman spoke proudly of how he spent his own money so that he could be in Washington and scoffed at the idea that the people sitting on the Mall represent a fringe element of American politics.
“These are some of the most caring people you will ever meet,” Ingman said. “These are the kind of people that I would see in my hometown. We are certainly not a bunch of loons.”
Though most of the fire was directed at Obama and the Democratic Congress, Republicans took some shots as well. Rob DeVoll of Charleston carried a sign telling Republicans to get a "spine." Though he disagrees with Democrats, he said, "I'm not a Democrat."
"I'm tired of the takeover," DeVoll said. "When Bush was in power he did the same thing."
Counter-protests were limited. But a small group of young people mocked the protesters, walking around in tuxes and evening gowns, chanting "Bring Back Bush," and holding signs that read "Fight socialism: End Medicare."
Though protesters had a wide variety of complaints, Obama's healthcare plan did come in for a mighty drubbing. One common printed sign read "Bury Obamacare with Kennedy."
"We will not tolerate a government takeover of our healthcare," Price said from the stage.
Michael M. Gleeson contributed to this report
The contents of this site are © 2009 Capitol Hill Publishing Corp., a subsisiary of News Communications, Inc.
The Hill Archives: Senate | House | Administration | Campaign | Business & Lobbying | Capital Living | Opinion
View News by Subject:
Defense & Homeland Security | Energy & Environment | Healthcare | Finance & Economy | Technology | Foreign Policy | Labor | Transportation & Infrastructure GO TO THE HILL HOME »Most Popular Stories
Most ViewedObama sets stage for using budget maneuver to pass health reformWilson hires professional TweeterWilson took caffeine pills in 2007Google online library battle hits HouseSpeaker Pelosi agrees to plan to scold Rep. Wilson for 'You lie' outburstEmailedObama sets stage for using budget maneuver to pass health reformI am sorryWilson hires professional TweeterBuffett tells Dems rich need to pay moreSupport democracy in Honduras (Rep. Dana Rohrabacher)DiscussedObama sets stage for using budget maneuver to pass health reformWilson hires professional TweeterSpeaker Pelosi agrees to plan to scold Rep. Wilson for 'You lie' outburstBuffett tells Dems rich need to pay moreLoud 9/12 protest reaches the CapitolHome/News » Most Viewed RSS Feed »
More Administration Headlines
Obama follows up address by pushing talking points on the roadGOP questions White House's 'fuzzy' math with stimulus jobsObama hits road to promote healthcare reform
More Administration Headlines »
Administration News RSS feed »
Briefing RoomKey Blago investigation subject deadSATURDAY ROUNDUPMcDonnell drops f-bomb during radio interview
More Briefing Room »
Congress BlogWhat Yesterday’s Poverty and Income Numbers Don’t Tell Us About Economic Hardship The Big Question, Sept. 11: Did Obama's speech improve the chances of passing healthcare reform?Address mental health in reform legislation
More Congress Blog »
Pundits BlogI am sorryWilson: Not that sorry ...What about the lobbyists, Mr. President?
More Pundits Blog »
Twitter RoomTown hall group receives bomb threatHatch tweets latest gripe with college football bowls TOP TWEETS
More Twitter Room »
Blogs News Feed
Cheri Jacobus Start over, Mr. President John Del Cecato No more kicking the can
A.B. Stoddard Lessons for Obama Ben Goddard Vietnamistan
More Columnists »
Get latest news from The Hill direct to your inbox, RSS reader and mobile devices.
Sep 12, 2009
- ► 2010 (18)
- Fourth Amendment Rights and Mandatory H1N1 Innocul...
- Americans should be allowed to know the contents o...
- Where's the Jobs? Send Out The Bloodhounds!
- Personality Cult Prayer TO Obama
- Questions on ACORN Suit Filed 9/23/09 in Circuit C...
- Govenment Health Care: A Reagan Perspective
- Who Are The Best Singers? You decide!
- ObamaNation In Retreat
- Personality Cult Song Sweet To The Ears of Totalit...
- Liberal Hypocrisy Exposed
- Government Hospital Hiding Malpractic in Medicine
- Propaganda Video:How The World Works
- HIghlights from the 9/12 Taxpayer Tea Party March ...
- If You Are Against HR3200, You May Be A Skinhead
- ▼ September (14)
Republican Leaders in the Senate & House
Senator/ Republican Leader Mitch McConnell's official YouTube channel http://mcconnell.senate.gov The official YouTube channel of Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell http://mcconnell.senate.gov/ http://www.youtube.com/user/RepublicanLeader
Senator Jim DeMint's Official YouTube Account Following the November elections in 2006, the senator stood up against big spenders in Congress and stopped over 10,000 wasteful pork projects. Famed Washington journalist Robert Novak called him a "hero."He was recently ranked as the Senate's most conservative member by National Journal and as the No. 1 senator voting for responsible tax and spending policies by the National Taxpayers Union. DeMint understands the greatness of a country is found in its people and values, not in its government http://www.youtube.com/user/SenJimDeMint
Republican Leader of the House, John Boehner House Republican Leader and a staunch opponent of pork-barrel politics, John is fighting to eliminate wasteful spending, create jobs, and balance the federal budget without raising taxes. He has challenged Republicans in the 111th Congress to be not just the party of “opposition,” but the party of better solutions to the challenges facing the American people. Under the new House GOP leadership team John leads, House Republicans have formed “solutions groups” to develop principled alternatives on the issues that matter most to American families and small businesses, and launched the GOP State Solutions project, an initiative aimed at bringing reform-minded Republicans at the state and federal levels together to promote common-sense solutions from outside the Beltway.
"Gone" Barack Obama
Barack Obama Countdown widget brought
to you by www.obamacountdownwidget.com
to you by www.obamacountdownwidget.com